Family caught in immigration Catch-22
by Sarah Miley
Aug 17, 2010 | 5903 views | 6 6 comments | 48 48 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Bianca Noerenberg (left) holds 1-year-old Mia Noerenberg while Benny Noerenberg (right) talks about losing his job at Detroit Diesel on Monday in Stansbury Park. The German family has been forced to sell everything to get back to Germany now that Benny’s work visa has expired.<br>- photography / Maegan Burr
Bianca Noerenberg (left) holds 1-year-old Mia Noerenberg while Benny Noerenberg (right) talks about losing his job at Detroit Diesel on Monday in Stansbury Park. The German family has been forced to sell everything to get back to Germany now that Benny’s work visa has expired.
- photography / Maegan Burr
slideshow
Yesterday was Mia Noerenberg’s first birthday — and perhaps the last she’ll celebrate in the country of her birth.

Mia’s parents, Benny, 31, and Bianca, 26, moved from Berlin, Germany to Erda two years ago for Benny’s job as an instrumentation technician at Detroit Diesel. The couple, both originally from Berlin, settled into American life feeling secure in Benny’s future with Daimler, the parent company of Detroit Diesel, after 13 years of working for the company.

Then, last week, Benny was fired and lost his job. Since his work visa was sponsored by Detroit Diesel, he has no legal means to stay in the country. Benny said he has two to four weeks to leave the country. That means the family must now conduct a fire sale of all the possessions in their current Stansbury Park home and return to Germany — not a scenario they ever envisioned.

“We have to sell pretty much everything we own to buy tickets to fly back and to have enough money to pay the container we have to order so we can put our car and stuff in, which is kind of expensive,” Benny said. “Every minute here costs us money we don’t have since I don’t have a job anymore and I can’t work anywhere else because of my [immigration] status.”

Detroit Diesel declined to comment on the reasons for Benny’s firing.

The Noerenbergs will be holding an open house sale this Thursday through Sunday at the home they’re renting in Stansbury Park from morning until evening each day. Benny estimates they’ll need about $8,000 to $9,000 to get themselves and a few personal belongings — clothing, photographs, a family bed, Mia’s bed, a car and two dogs — back to Germany.

“The rest is for sale,” he said. “We have to sell everything — furniture, every electronic item because we can’t use them in Germany because of the different power supply and different connectors.”

Other items, including yard care equipment, will also be sold.

Benny said some people, after hearing their story, have advised them to just stay in the country illegally.

“I don’t think that’s the right way and we have a little baby,” Benny said. “We have to take care of her too.”

The couple plans on living with Bianca’s parents in Berlin until they can get back on their feet. After building a new life here and making friends, Bianca said it will be hard to leave that all behind. Right now, however, they’re still struggling to come to terms with their situation.

“The first few days after we had a really hard time,” Benny said. “If you are not in that situation like we are you have no idea what’s going on and how hard it is.”

Sandy Critchlow, an agent with Prudential Real Estate whom the Noerenberg family rents from, said it’s been difficult to see what the family is going through.

“We all complain everyday about the traffic, price of gas and the heat,” she said. “What if you were faced with nowhere to live, nowhere to go? Now they’ve got to sell everything — everything that they’ve worked hard to buy — and try to get the money together to go home.”

The couple does want to come back to the United States, but with a Green Card next time.

“The United States was our dream,” Bianca said. “It was our big dream.”

Benny said he was hoping for a new challenge in his work here and the chance to see all the country had to offer.

“There are so many things to enjoy, but we never had a chance to do all of that,” he said. “We will come back, but just with a Green Card.”

The family’s yard sale will be at 5483 Lorraine Way in Stansbury. An account has also been set up at Wells Fargo in the family’s name for those who would like to donate.

Sarah Miley: swest@tooeletranscript.com

Comments
(6)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
jackel22
|
August 23, 2010
It's really no surprise the way he was treated. Once they decided they were going to fire him, it's only a matter of time before he would be picked apart for the way he worked. Anybody reading this could be fired from a job if their employer really wanted to dissect the details of how you work (i.e. not being at your desk at any particular point in the day or taking a personal call). Detroit Diesel used to be a great place for the local community to go to for a great job with a decent future, now you must be on your toes and watch the knives that are being thrown around and hope one doesn't stick you in the back.

All the best to Benny and Bianca in their future travels.
ak4mc
|
August 20, 2010
If they had come here illegally they'd be safe, if the feds had their way.
dwalk
|
August 20, 2010
My earlier post has nothing to do with the Noerenbergs. It is in response to sfbrown only.

I wish the Noerenbergs the best, but they knew they were on a work visa and I don't believe that they were leaving Germany seeking asylum from dangerous tyranny.

If his employment was terminated unjustly, I am sure the courts will rectify the matter. I find it interesting that everyone is quiet about the reasons for termination, though.

dwalk
|
August 20, 2010
sfbrown,

You left out the paragraph where it states "Give us your criminals, pedofiles, free loaders, those willing to take advantage of U.S. social programs, those willing to vote illegally, AND those willing to use someone else's SSN and I.D.s.

We citizens already taken advantage of will show compassion though, because we understand that it completely slipped your mind.

How many were arrested yesterday with gang affiliations?

How many were arrested yesterday with false SSN's and I.D.'s?

How many were arrested yesterday were drug dealers taking advantage of your relatives, children and grandchildren?

Jus Curious?
sfbrown
|
August 18, 2010
WOW Friend of Utah you would actually write something like that? You should be ashamed. All of us are from somewhere else. I commend their dignity for not taking advantage of our social services and leaving here willfully and honestly. I wish them the best of luck and hope that everything works out for them, here or anywhere else in the world they wish to live. Remember what is printed on the Statue of Liberty to welcome all "Give us your poor, your tired, your huddled masses longing to be free..."
friendofutah
|
August 18, 2010
Oh Darn. I feel bad for them, but maybe they will give the job to a CITIZEN. I have friends and family that desperately need jobs.
report abuse...

Comments will be posted after review. Please allow up to 24 hours for comment approval.

Readers are solely responsible for the content of the comments they post here. Comments do not necessarily reflect the opinion or approval of the Tooele Transcript-Bulletin. Abusive comments and users are subject to rejection or removal without notification.

We will reject and remove comments that contain any of the following: Potentially libelous statements; personal attacks, insults or threats; profanity or obscene references; copyrighted articles or information used without permission; promotional messages of a commercial nature; links to other Web sites; comments unrelated to the topic of the article.

By posting a comment, you are agreeing to abide by these guidelines. Violation of these guidelines may result in a user being barred from posting on the Web site.

Online Edition
Shadowbox Test Site

THIS WEEK'S ADS

BARGAIN BUGGY'S
To Flash Zoom Click HERE
Click HERE to visit our website



BIG O TIRES
To Flash Zoom Click HERE
Click HERE to visit our website



QUALITY AUTOMOTIVE
To Flash Zoom Click HERE
Click HERE to visit our website



RITZ THEATRES
To Flash Zoom Click HERE



MOUNTAIN WEST MEDICAL CENTER
To Flash Zoom Click HERE
Click HERE to visit our website



AMERICAN BURGERS
To Flash Zoom Click HERE
Click HERE to visit our website



DAVID K. PALMER
To Flash Zoom Click HERE



TRANSCRIPT BULLETIN PUBLISHING
To Flash Zoom Click HERE
Click HERE to visit our website